I just came across this great old chart of the Bahamas from a book from 1885. I played with it a bit in photoshop and printed one out, it looks pretty good. It came from a history of the Bahamas that I hadn't come across before at:
http://www.jabezcorner.com/Grand_Bahama/History.htm
CLICK FOR FULL SIZED IMAGE
Merry Christmas, a little late!